New York, NY Italian Delivery from Pietros - NY

Don Dinnerville
Don Dinnerville
03/19/2024
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
Absolutely LOVED this place and would be a regular if I didn't live in Texas. Definitely recommend making a reservation. I gave the server a choice of a few dishes, and of those he recommended the Meat Ravioli. I tweaked the order to have pink sauce instead of marinara, and I CLEANED THE PLATE (which I never do). If / when I ever make it back to NYC, I guarantee I'll come back!
Mike G
Mike G
03/04/2024
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really). Vegetarian options: Veggie options lacking - just veggies doused in olive oil
Mike G
Mike G
02/27/2024
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really).
Stacy P
Stacy P
12/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
Love this family style Italian restaurant! The ambiance made us feel at home. And the food and service was excellent. We liked all the dishes we ordered. Highly recommend their generously portioned lasagna. Great history of loyal customers… I can see why it’s a favorite place for many local New Yorkers and families. We will be back again soon.
Scott Deutchman
Scott Deutchman
12/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
This is a well established Italian restaurant that feels like home.Off the beaten path,a reasonably priced,great tasting restaurant.
Carla
Carla
10/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
This place is a MUST on every trip to NYC! We stumbled upon Pietro’s on a previous visit to NYC and have to come back every time we visit! Don’t even hesitate one second to go here! Chicken Parmigiana- mwwwuah! Probably the best I’ve ever had!!! 10/10 Veal Scallopini- mwwwwuah! 10/10 again - the best I’ve ever had! Caesar salad - WITH anchovies!! Yes you don’t know they are in there but the flavour!!!! OMG! Delicious! 10/10 Spaghetti with meatballs - 10/10 You can’t go wrong - it’s a magical little hidden gem in mid-town that will rock your world! Great service- top notch actually and wine flows! Crème Brule for dessert 🤯
Art Gilliland
Art Gilliland
09/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
I eat alone traveling for work, a lot. This is a great neighborhood place which made me feel welcome. The food was solid, but what made it great was the atmosphere. It was obvious that the brothers who run it like each other and they like what they do. They know the regulars and the place was full with them on a Tuesday night. I sat at the bar and enjoyed the show. I had Cesar (which was great) and chicken parm (good). I wouldn’t come here for cocktails or wine. That said, I will come back because of the solid food and the friendly treatment.
Liat Weinstock
Liat Weinstock
06/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
This is an establishment in NYC It’s a fantastic steakhouse that was opened in 1932 The service is professional The food is great The atmosphere is cozy
Matthew Cooper
Matthew Cooper
03/25/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did. The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement. My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious. I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.
Matthew Cooper
Matthew Cooper
03/02/2023
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did. The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement. My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious. I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.
Emily Robison
Emily Robison
03/25/2022
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
The service was fantastic, I felt like our waiter was always checking on us and my water glass was never more than half empty. Fettuccine Alfredo was perfect, creamy and not to much garlic. The Ceasar salad was great too. The decor wasn't anything special and felt a little out of date but the food made up for that!
Robert Crowther
Robert Crowther
03/25/2019
star 0 star 1 star 2 star 3 star 4
Excellent old school Italian spot. Surprisingly good steak. Service was okay and wines by the glass not great but that's not why you're here. The food is traditional NYC Italian and every dish was superb.

232 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017

— Closed for Easter Sunday —

Browse Our Favorites

Italian in New York, NY Delivering to:

10017

10109

10114

10102

10170

10166

10167

10081

10087

10169

10172

10177

10174

10171

10165

10176

10173

10055

10154

10150

10152

10178

10022

10168

10111

10020

10175

10112

10016

10103

11217

11373

07094

11216

07306

07096

10031

11238

10451

07304

11379

11369

07308

11231

10455

10039

11371

07097

07657

07303

07399

07395

10032

10474

11213

11233

11215

11374

11385

11368

11225

10456

10452

07650

11426

11023

11411

07626

07407

11024

10704

07206

10551

11413

10104 

10120 

10155 

10153 

10151

10122 

10105 

10123 

10118 

11109 

10065 

10036 

10107 

10101 

10119 

10121 

10010 

10106 

10116 

10060 

10110 

10001 

10018 

10199 

10242 

10044 

11120 

10249 

10019 

10021 

10459

07024

11232

07305

11212

11207

11375

07072

11356

10473

11421

07643

07660

11203

11226

11218

07074

10033

11208

10457

10040

10453

11351

07032

11354

07073

07605

07071

10472

11367

11352

11355

11416

10460

11021

10303

11027

07013

07042

11026

07628

07106

10553

07043

10023 

10113 

10003 

10162 

10276 

10075

10011 

10009 

10069 

10028 

11101 

10002 

11222 

11106 

10012 

10158 

10014 

10128 

07086

11102 

10013 

11104 

07093 

10278 

07030 

10024 

10029 

11211 

07087 

10108 

11424

11220

11415

11386

11380

11418

11219

07031

11417

07608

10034

07699

11236

07606

07070

10462

11357

11210

11239

10468

11230

07002

07603

07099

11419

10458

07075

11204

07632

11435

07105

07604

07029

11414

11005

10803

11004

07051

07503

07111

11020

11695

11694

11422

10117 

10124 

10125 

10126 

10129 

10130 

10131 

10132 

10133 

10138 

10156 

10157 

10159 

10160 

10163 

10164 

10179 

10185 

10203 

10211 

10212 

10213 

10256 

10258 

10259 

10260 

10261 

10265 

10268 

10269 

10461

10463

11358

11365

07631

11209

11228

07666

11431

11420

11405

11425

11439

11451

11499

11366

11432

07057

10465

07602

07601

10467

07104

07109

11360

07014

07644

11234

11433

07101

07184

07188

07189

07191

07050

07207

07627

11697

11001

07513

11002

07205

07504

10805

10272 

10273 

10274 

10275 

10285 

10286 

10025 

10090 

10007 

11103 

10282 

10279 

10008 

11251 

10038 

10080 

11377 

10277 

10271 

07047 

10045 

07310 

10005 

10270 

10035 

10026 

10006 

10280 

10043 

11105 

07192

07193

07195

07198

07199

07102

11252

10469

07175

11229

11436

11361

11359

07110

11214

11223

07055

07114

10471

10301

11423

10310

07026

11364

07107

07607

10475

07670

07103

11434

11412

11235

10466

10311

10552

07652

07208

11042

07653

11692

07649

11003

07202

11427

11206 

11378 

10041 

11242 

10281 

11205 

11243 

11256 

10115 

11202 

11201 

11241 

11249 

07307 

07302 

10027 

11247 

11370 

11237 

11245 

10037 

10454 

11372 

07010 

07022 

11221 

10030 

10004 

07020 

07311 

07012

07621

10470

07003

10304

07662

10305

11363

07201

10464

07108

10705

11224

10302

10313

07019

11428

11430

07017

07663

07015

07011

11022

11362

07661

11429

11693

07646

07028

11437

07112

07018

10550

10702

07641

07620

10701

10314

11096

07410

10802

10708

07079

Don Dinnerville
Don Dinnerville
03/19/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Absolutely LOVED this place and would be a regular if I didn't live in Texas. Definitely recommend making a reservation. I gave the server a choice of a few dishes, and of those he recommended the Meat Ravioli. I tweaked the order to have pink sauce instead of marinara, and I CLEANED THE PLATE (which I never do). If / when I ever make it back to NYC, I guarantee I'll come back!

Mike G
Mike G
03/04/2024

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really). Vegetarian options: Veggie options lacking - just veggies doused in olive oil

Stacy P
Stacy P
12/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Love this family style Italian restaurant! The ambiance made us feel at home. And the food and service was excellent. We liked all the dishes we ordered. Highly recommend their generously portioned lasagna. Great history of loyal customers… I can see why it’s a favorite place for many local New Yorkers and families. We will be back again soon.

Scott Deutchman
Scott Deutchman
12/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is a well established Italian restaurant that feels like home.Off the beaten path,a reasonably priced,great tasting restaurant.

Carla
Carla
10/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This place is a MUST on every trip to NYC! We stumbled upon Pietro’s on a previous visit to NYC and have to come back every time we visit! Don’t even hesitate one second to go here! Chicken Parmigiana- mwwwuah! Probably the best I’ve ever had!!! 10/10 Veal Scallopini- mwwwwuah! 10/10 again - the best I’ve ever had! Caesar salad - WITH anchovies!! Yes you don’t know they are in there but the flavour!!!! OMG! Delicious! 10/10 Spaghetti with meatballs - 10/10 You can’t go wrong - it’s a magical little hidden gem in mid-town that will rock your world! Great service- top notch actually and wine flows! Crème Brule for dessert 🤯

Art Gilliland
Art Gilliland
09/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
I eat alone traveling for work, a lot. This is a great neighborhood place which made me feel welcome. The food was solid, but what made it great was the atmosphere. It was obvious that the brothers who run it like each other and they like what they do. They know the regulars and the place was full with them on a Tuesday night. I sat at the bar and enjoyed the show. I had Cesar (which was great) and chicken parm (good). I wouldn’t come here for cocktails or wine. That said, I will come back because of the solid food and the friendly treatment.

Liat Weinstock
Liat Weinstock
06/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
This is an establishment in NYC It’s a fantastic steakhouse that was opened in 1932 The service is professional The food is great The atmosphere is cozy

Matthew Cooper
Matthew Cooper
03/25/2023

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did. The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement. My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious. I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.

Emily Robison
Emily Robison
03/25/2022

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
The service was fantastic, I felt like our waiter was always checking on us and my water glass was never more than half empty. Fettuccine Alfredo was perfect, creamy and not to much garlic. The Ceasar salad was great too. The decor wasn't anything special and felt a little out of date but the food made up for that!

Robert Crowther
Robert Crowther
03/25/2019

star 0
star 1
star 2
star 3
star 4
Excellent old school Italian spot. Surprisingly good steak. Service was okay and wines by the glass not great but that's not why you're here. The food is traditional NYC Italian and every dish was superb.

Contact Us