232 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017
— Closed for Easter Sunday —
New York, NY Italian Delivery from Pietros - NY
Don Dinnerville
03/19/2024
03/19/2024
Absolutely LOVED this place and would be a regular if I didn't live in Texas. Definitely recommend making a reservation. I gave the server a choice of a few dishes, and of those he recommended the Meat Ravioli. I tweaked the order to have pink sauce instead of marinara, and I CLEANED THE PLATE (which I never do). If / when I ever make it back to NYC, I guarantee I'll come back!
Mike G
03/04/2024
03/04/2024
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really). Vegetarian options: Veggie options lacking - just veggies doused in olive oil
Mike G
02/27/2024
02/27/2024
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had.
As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really).
Stacy P
12/25/2023
12/25/2023
Love this family style Italian restaurant! The ambiance made us feel at home. And the food and service was excellent. We liked all the dishes we ordered. Highly recommend their generously portioned lasagna. Great history of loyal customers… I can see why it’s a favorite place for many local New Yorkers and families. We will be back again soon.
Scott Deutchman
12/25/2023
12/25/2023
This is a well established Italian restaurant that feels like home.Off the beaten path,a reasonably priced,great tasting restaurant.
Carla
10/25/2023
10/25/2023
This place is a MUST on every trip to NYC! We stumbled upon Pietro’s on a previous visit to NYC and have to come back every time we visit! Don’t even hesitate one second to go here! Chicken Parmigiana- mwwwuah! Probably the best I’ve ever had!!! 10/10 Veal Scallopini- mwwwwuah! 10/10 again - the best I’ve ever had! Caesar salad - WITH anchovies!! Yes you don’t know they are in there but the flavour!!!! OMG! Delicious! 10/10 Spaghetti with meatballs - 10/10 You can’t go wrong - it’s a magical little hidden gem in mid-town that will rock your world! Great service- top notch actually and wine flows! Crème Brule for dessert 🤯
Art Gilliland
09/25/2023
09/25/2023
I eat alone traveling for work, a lot. This is a great neighborhood place which made me feel welcome. The food was solid, but what made it great was the atmosphere. It was obvious that the brothers who run it like each other and they like what they do. They know the regulars and the place was full with them on a Tuesday night. I sat at the bar and enjoyed the show. I had Cesar (which was great) and chicken parm (good). I wouldn’t come here for cocktails or wine. That said, I will come back because of the solid food and the friendly treatment.
Liat Weinstock
06/25/2023
06/25/2023
This is an establishment in NYC It’s a fantastic steakhouse that was opened in 1932 The service is professional The food is great The atmosphere is cozy
Matthew Cooper
03/25/2023
03/25/2023
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did. The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement. My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious. I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.
Matthew Cooper
03/02/2023
03/02/2023
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did.
The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement.
My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious.
I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.
Emily Robison
03/25/2022
03/25/2022
The service was fantastic, I felt like our waiter was always checking on us and my water glass was never more than half empty. Fettuccine Alfredo was perfect, creamy and not to much garlic. The Ceasar salad was great too. The decor wasn't anything special and felt a little out of date but the food made up for that!
Robert Crowther
03/25/2019
03/25/2019
Excellent old school Italian spot. Surprisingly good steak. Service was okay and wines by the glass not great but that's not why you're here. The food is traditional NYC Italian and every dish was superb.
Italian in New York, NY Delivering to:
10017
10109
10114
10102
10170
10166
10167
10081
10087
10169
10172
10177
10174
10171
10165
10176
10173
10055
10154
10150
10152
10178
10022
10168
10111
10020
10175
10112
10016
10103
11217
11373
07094
11216
07306
07096
10031
11238
10451
07304
11379
11369
07308
11231
10455
10039
11371
07097
07657
07303
07399
07395
10032
10474
11213
11233
11215
11374
11385
11368
11225
10456
10452
07650
11426
11023
11411
07626
07407
11024
10704
07206
10551
11413
10104
10120
10155
10153
10151
10122
10105
10123
10118
11109
10065
10036
10107
10101
10119
10121
10010
10106
10116
10060
10110
10001
10018
10199
10242
10044
11120
10249
10019
10021
10459
07024
11232
07305
11212
11207
11375
07072
11356
10473
11421
07643
07660
11203
11226
11218
07074
10033
11208
10457
10040
10453
11351
07032
11354
07073
07605
07071
10472
11367
11352
11355
11416
10460
11021
10303
11027
07013
07042
11026
07628
07106
10553
07043
10023
10113
10003
10162
10276
10075
10011
10009
10069
10028
11101
10002
11222
11106
10012
10158
10014
10128
07086
11102
10013
11104
07093
10278
07030
10024
10029
11211
07087
10108
11424
11220
11415
11386
11380
11418
11219
07031
11417
07608
10034
07699
11236
07606
07070
10462
11357
11210
11239
10468
11230
07002
07603
07099
11419
10458
07075
11204
07632
11435
07105
07604
07029
11414
11005
10803
11004
07051
07503
07111
11020
11695
11694
11422
10117
10124
10125
10126
10129
10130
10131
10132
10133
10138
10156
10157
10159
10160
10163
10164
10179
10185
10203
10211
10212
10213
10256
10258
10259
10260
10261
10265
10268
10269
10461
10463
11358
11365
07631
11209
11228
07666
11431
11420
11405
11425
11439
11451
11499
11366
11432
07057
10465
07602
07601
10467
07104
07109
11360
07014
07644
11234
11433
07101
07184
07188
07189
07191
07050
07207
07627
11697
11001
07513
11002
07205
07504
10805
10272
10273
10274
10275
10285
10286
10025
10090
10007
11103
10282
10279
10008
11251
10038
10080
11377
10277
10271
07047
10045
07310
10005
10270
10035
10026
10006
10280
10043
11105
07192
07193
07195
07198
07199
07102
11252
10469
07175
11229
11436
11361
11359
07110
11214
11223
07055
07114
10471
10301
11423
10310
07026
11364
07107
07607
10475
07670
07103
11434
11412
11235
10466
10311
10552
07652
07208
11042
07653
11692
07649
11003
07202
11427
11206
11378
10041
11242
10281
11205
11243
11256
10115
11202
11201
11241
11249
07307
07302
10027
11247
11370
11237
11245
10037
10454
11372
07010
07022
11221
10030
10004
07020
07311
07012
07621
10470
07003
10304
07662
10305
11363
07201
10464
07108
10705
11224
10302
10313
07019
11428
11430
07017
07663
07015
07011
11022
11362
07661
11429
11693
07646
07028
11437
07112
07018
10550
10702
07641
07620
10701
10314
11096
07410
10802
10708
07079
Don Dinnerville
03/19/2024
03/19/2024
Absolutely LOVED this place and would be a regular if I didn't live in Texas. Definitely recommend making a reservation. I gave the server a choice of a few dishes, and of those he recommended the Meat Ravioli. I tweaked the order to have pink sauce instead of marinara, and I CLEANED THE PLATE (which I never do). If / when I ever make it back to NYC, I guarantee I'll come back!
Mike G
03/04/2024
03/04/2024
Great classic NY Italian spot. Highly recommend - one of the best chicken parms I have ever had. As usually the case with Italian spots, not a ton of options for a vegan eater (or vegetarian really). Vegetarian options: Veggie options lacking - just veggies doused in olive oil
Stacy P
12/25/2023
12/25/2023
Love this family style Italian restaurant! The ambiance made us feel at home. And the food and service was excellent. We liked all the dishes we ordered. Highly recommend their generously portioned lasagna. Great history of loyal customers… I can see why it’s a favorite place for many local New Yorkers and families. We will be back again soon.
Scott Deutchman
12/25/2023
12/25/2023
This is a well established Italian restaurant that feels like home.Off the beaten path,a reasonably priced,great tasting restaurant.
Carla
10/25/2023
10/25/2023
This place is a MUST on every trip to NYC! We stumbled upon Pietro’s on a previous visit to NYC and have to come back every time we visit! Don’t even hesitate one second to go here! Chicken Parmigiana- mwwwuah! Probably the best I’ve ever had!!! 10/10 Veal Scallopini- mwwwwuah! 10/10 again - the best I’ve ever had! Caesar salad - WITH anchovies!! Yes you don’t know they are in there but the flavour!!!! OMG! Delicious! 10/10 Spaghetti with meatballs - 10/10 You can’t go wrong - it’s a magical little hidden gem in mid-town that will rock your world! Great service- top notch actually and wine flows! Crème Brule for dessert 🤯
Art Gilliland
09/25/2023
09/25/2023
I eat alone traveling for work, a lot. This is a great neighborhood place which made me feel welcome. The food was solid, but what made it great was the atmosphere. It was obvious that the brothers who run it like each other and they like what they do. They know the regulars and the place was full with them on a Tuesday night. I sat at the bar and enjoyed the show. I had Cesar (which was great) and chicken parm (good). I wouldn’t come here for cocktails or wine. That said, I will come back because of the solid food and the friendly treatment.
Liat Weinstock
06/25/2023
06/25/2023
This is an establishment in NYC It’s a fantastic steakhouse that was opened in 1932 The service is professional The food is great The atmosphere is cozy
Matthew Cooper
03/25/2023
03/25/2023
Excellent food, brilliant service, and a lovely atmosphere. I was staying on the opposite side of town but took the trip over here specifically to try this restaurant and I am very glad I did. The "Famous Chopped Salad" was great. It has a good mix of veggies in with the greens and the dressing is a good complement. My main course was the chicken parmesan with a half order of fettuccini alfredo. The chicken parmesan's pictures on Google Maps were why I came and it exceeded my expectations. The fettuccini alfredo was likewise delicious. I would be remiss if I did not also comment on the service - top notch. David, the manager, and Damian, my waiter, were both great and I got everything I wanted. I will visit definitely visit again.
Emily Robison
03/25/2022
03/25/2022
The service was fantastic, I felt like our waiter was always checking on us and my water glass was never more than half empty. Fettuccine Alfredo was perfect, creamy and not to much garlic. The Ceasar salad was great too. The decor wasn't anything special and felt a little out of date but the food made up for that!
Robert Crowther
03/25/2019
03/25/2019
Excellent old school Italian spot. Surprisingly good steak. Service was okay and wines by the glass not great but that's not why you're here. The food is traditional NYC Italian and every dish was superb.
